Press start: every story, 2+ sources

Home / Culture & Esports

The EU said no to a law on dead games. What publishers still have to do

The Commission declined to require playable games after shutdown. Its June answer still sets three jobs due by the end of 2026, and a code of conduct.

Culture & Esports 4 min read

Photo: Multicherry, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

When a publisher switches off the servers of a game you bought, can the law make it keep the game playable? On June 16, the European Commission answered no, and the campaigners behind “Stop Destroying Videogames” lost their central demand. The reply was not empty, though. It contains commitments with a deadline of the end of 2026, which is why the story is still live in November.

What was asked, and what came back

The European Citizens’ Initiative collected more than 1.29 million signatures across at least seven member states, according to the European Audiovisual Observatory’s summary. It was backed by the “Stop Killing Games” project started by the YouTuber Ross Scott. heise online notes the triggers: Ubisoft’s shutdown of The Crew in April 2025, which led consumer advocates to begin a procedure in France, and a later Sony server closure for the VR shooter Firewall Ultra.

The Commission said it could not “propose a legal obligation now,” pointing to rights holders’ existing intellectual property rights. Commissioner Michael McGrath’s line, quoted by heise, was that video game providers “must treat consumers fairly, even when they decide to discontinue a game.” The Observatory adds that the Commission relied on existing rules, including the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive and the directive on unfair contract terms.

The three jobs due by year end

The part publishers should read is in Lewis Silkin’s analysis, written by lawyers Laura Harper, Aaron Trebble and Helen Hart. They list commitments the Commission set itself for the end of 2026:

  1. Start talks with industry and consumer groups on a voluntary code of conduct for handling the end of a game’s life.
  2. Work with consumer bodies and authorities to publicise the rights consumers already have.
  3. Report on how the Digital Content Directive (2019/770) applies to discontinued digital content and services.

The sources do not describe these identically. heise speaks of a dialogue on better industry standards and does not mention a “code.” The Observatory refers to exploring a self-regulatory code on “sunsetting” standards. I read the common thread as dialogue first, with a code as the possible product. Anyone expecting a finished code in December should check the Commission’s own channels, since none of the three outlets says it has been published.

Why the law still matters to a refund

Lewis Silkin reminds readers that consumers already have remedies under the Digital Content Directive when content does not conform to the contract, including a proportionate refund in some cases. The firm expects consumer authorities to look hard at the clarity of what players are told about a game’s lifespan, online dependencies, end-of-service terms, in-game currencies and refunds. That is advice to publishers: disclosure is where enforcement is likely to start.

Publishers argue, per heise, that a duty to keep servers running would make games much more expensive and expose them to liability for privately run servers. The campaigners’ answer was that they would keep pushing, along with the European Parliament, to have preservation rules included in the Digital Fairness Act. SPD member of the European Parliament Tiemo Wölken called the Commission’s approach “meaningless symbolic politics.”

Elsewhere and what is unknown

Lewis Silkin puts the EU decision in a wider setting: the UK Government has said it has no plan to change consumer law on disabling games, while in California the Protect Our Games Act would require publishers to give notice when ending a game and offer continued use or a refund. Whether that bill has passed is not covered by the sources I read.

A page related to the Lewis Silkin article suggests the Commission has since published a Digital Fairness Act proposal. I have not read it, so I cannot say whether it addresses game shutdowns, and nobody should treat this article as an answer to that.

The practical reading is narrow. There is no EU rule that forces a game to stay playable, and there are rules about being honest on what was sold. The next test is the end-of-year report and any voluntary code. For a player buying a service-dependent game today, the useful habit is to read the end-of-service terms before paying, because the law that exists is about disclosure and refunds, not preservation.

Sources

  1. heise online: Stop Killing Games, EU Commission rejects gamers heise.de
  2. Lewis Silkin: European Commission stops short of imposing mandatory requirements lewissilkin.com
  3. European Audiovisual Observatory (IRIS Merlin): Stop Killing Videogames, the Commission response merlin.obs.coe.int